A former staffer on “The Kyle & Jackie O Show” has lifted the lid on what life was like behind the scenes, as the dust settles on the news that the show is over.
Appearing on the podcast “Behind the Mic with Mike E,” Mitchell Coombs, former staffer-turned-social media creator, reflected on the infamous “Virgin Mary” controversy that erupted while he was responsible for producing content for the show’s social channels.
During the episode, Coombs described to host Michael Etheridge the intense pressure to produce a constant stream of viral material for the show’s online platforms – a pace that, he said, ultimately contributed to the clip being posted.
According to Coombs, he had initially flagged the segment internally as potentially offensive and had intentionally left the footage unedited in the team’s internal “content bank.” But on a hectic day when new material was urgently needed, the clip was uploaded.
Coombs said he realised almost immediately that something had gone wrong.
“I checked the video after like 20 minutes. I was on a Tinder date… and I was like, ‘Oh f—.’ People weren’t even outraged yet; it was long-time listeners saying they were genuinely hurt. I deleted the video immediately, but the damage was done.”
Love Film & TV?
Get your daily dose of everything happening in music, film and TV in Australia and abroad.
The resurfaced story arrives as the future of ARN’s flagship breakfast franchise remains uncertain. In a statement posted to the ASX on Tuesday evening, ARN Media confirmed that Jacqueline Henderson had formally stepped away from the show.
“ARN Media Limited [ASX: A1N] announces that Ms Jacqueline Henderson has given notice that she ‘cannot continue to work with Mr Kyle Sandilands,’” the statement read. “Accordingly, ARN has terminated the services agreement with Henderson Media Pty Ltd, under which Ms Henderson presents ‘The Kyle and Jackie O Show’. Ms Henderson will cease to present ‘The Kyle and Jackie O Show.’ ARN has also offered to Ms Henderson the possibility of an alternative show on the ARN network.”
The decision effectively ends one of Australian radio’s most successful and lucrative on-air partnerships.
In 2023, Henderson and Kyle Sandilands signed a 10-year contract reportedly worth around $200 million with ARN, locking the pair into KIIS FM breakfast until 2034. That deal underpinned ARN’s broader strategy to scale “The Kyle & Jackie O Show” beyond Sydney, including its high-profile Melbourne launch in 2024.
As previously reported by Mediaweek, the scale of that investment meant the program carried enormous strategic weight within the business, with executives effectively wagering that national expansion would deliver the audience growth and advertising returns required to justify the outlay.
With Henderson’s services agreement now terminated, ARN can no longer rely on the original structure of that blockbuster arrangement. The pairing that anchored the 10-year strategy is finished. Whether Sandilands remedies the alleged breach – or whether ARN moves to terminate his agreement with Quasar Media – will determine the next chapter.
The breakdown of the partnership is also raising questions among investors about how the contracts underpinning the deal may now play out. Investor David Kingston of K Capital, who holds a small stake in ARN Media but enough to stir debate at its annual general meeting, believed the situation may prove more complex than simply enforcing a notice period.
Speaking to The Australian Financial Review, Kingston suggested legal protections around Jacqueline “Jackie O” Henderson’s exit are likely already in play. “I’d be surprised if Jackie’s lawyers have not handled this in a manner to preserve their claim,” he said.
View this post on Instagram
Despite the upheaval, host of “The Quarter Hour Podcast” and media commentator Wade Kingsley believed Sandilands is unlikely to disappear from broadcasting altogether. “I can’t see a world where Kyle isn’t a broadcaster,” Kingsley told Mediaweek.
“Whether that’s on a podcast, whether he’s on talkback radio or whether he’s back on the breakfast show. I think when you’re on the number one FM Breakfast show in Sydney, and you’ve lived all your life for this opportunity, I think you’d still crawl over cut glass to keep that opportunity. Kyle’s highly ambitious, but also highly competent,” he said.
Kingsley also questioned some of the characterisation of the on-air incident that triggered the breakdown between the pair. “I think it’s interesting that what was clearly one person admonishing another is now being framed as a fight. It didn’t sound like a fight. It sounded like one person publicly admonishing and embarrassing a coworker.”
For ARN, however, the bigger challenge may be extracting value from two high-profile personalities who no longer want to work together.
Kingsley said the network’s most pragmatic option may be to separate the pair and build new formats around each.
“Clearly, he’ll have to try and do that without Jackie, which will affect ratings, but hopefully Jackie finds something within ARN that she’s happy to do and that ARN are happy for her to do that.” He suggested the most pragmatic path forward for ARN Media may be to lean into the individual strengths of both presenters, even if they are no longer willing to work together.
In his view, the network’s best option would be to renegotiate the existing arrangements so it can use the services of Sandilands and Henderson separately – and ultimately make each performer more profitable on their own.
Meanwhile, Henderson’s recent claims that she can no longer work with Sandilands also stand in stark contrast to her earlier description of their relationship. In her memoir “The Whole Truth,” released last year, Henderson wrote at length about the closeness of their decades-long partnership.
“Take Kyle,” she wrote towards the end of the book. “I love him unconditionally for all his wonderful traits, and I love him even more for his perceived flaws. I wouldn’t be where I am today without Kyle’s belief in us and his incredible talent.”
She continued: “He’s always had my back, and I’ve had his.” The passage concludes with a line that now reads with particular resonance given the current circumstances. “Our bond is unbreakable, standing the test of time, and I know we’ll remain loyal to each other forever.”